When you're planning a winter escape to warmer climates, you'll face the classic vacation dilemma: cruise ship or all-inclusive resort? Both options promise sun-soaked days and worry-free experiences, but they deliver distinctly different types of getaways. While you might picture yourself sipping cocktails by an infinity pool at a Caribbean resort, you could just as easily envision watching the sunset from a ship's deck as you sail toward your next port of call. Before you commit to either choice, you'll want to contemplate several key factors that could make one option noticeably better suited to your ideal winter break.
Questions
What's Your Preferred Romantic Getaway?
Key Points
- Both cruises and all-inclusive resorts offer compelling winter getaway options, with resorts being better for relaxation and predictable costs while cruises excel at variety and entertainment.
- All-inclusive resorts provide transparent pricing and easier budgeting without hidden fees or additional charges.
- Standard resort rooms offer significantly more living space compared to typical cruise cabins, enhancing overall comfort.
- Cruises enable exploration of multiple destinations while resorts provide a consistent experience in one location.
- Resort stays allow complete scheduling freedom whereas cruises operate on fixed timetables.
Article Index
Ultimately there is no right or wrong answer here and many people enjoy both options when it comes to escaping winter weather. As the cruise industry expands though, we're seeing considerable innovation. The most exciting of which is Virgin Voyages that is proving to be a disruptor in a centuries-old cruise industry. They have introduced many innovations to the industry such as including wifi internet for free, including speciality dining options in the price of the cruise fare, and generally providing a more "resort like" atmosphere.
Unlike other cruise lines that focus their best ships on longer seven-day voyages, Virgin Voyages offers a great variety of 5 day voyages that are perfect for a winter getaway for couples.
Oh and check this out ... they are adults only too, so no kids to worry about either!
Understanding Costs and Value
When comparing the costs between cruises and all-inclusive resorts, you'll need to look beyond the initial price tags. While cruises often tempt travelers with lower base fares, you might find yourself reaching for your wallet more often once you're on board.
A proper cost comparison should factor in those sneaky extras like drink packages, Wi-Fi, and specialty dining that can quickly add up. A typical weeklong cruise starts around $2,050 for a couple. All-inclusive resorts tend to be more transparent with their pricing since they offer minimal upfront planning.
You'll find that expense tracking is much simpler at all-inclusive resorts, where most amenities are wrapped into your upfront payment. No need to think twice about ordering that poolside margarita or signing up for morning yoga - it's all covered!
You May Also Like This Related Article:
However, if you're not big on alcoholic beverages or fancy dining, a cruise might actually work better for your budget since you'll only pay for what you use.
For families looking to keep costs predictable, all-inclusives often win out with their built-in activities and endless food options.
But don't count cruises out just yet - if you're strategic about your onboard spending and love the idea of waking up in a new port each day, you will probably find that seafaring adventure gives you the best bang for your buck.
Space and Room Considerations
Space stands out as one of the biggest differences between cruises and all-inclusive resorts. Depending on your own personal preferences, this might be a minor aspect of your ideal vacation experience or it might be something you simply can't accept in terms of the relatively cramped spaces offered by a typical cruise ship cabin.
You'll immediately notice that resort room size offers considerably more breathing room - often double what you'd find in a cruise cabin. When you're spending a week or more in paradise, having that extra space to spread out, unpack properly, and enjoy spa-style bathrooms makes a huge difference in your comfort level. Basic cruise cabins typically range from 150 to 250 square feet.
Resort amenities also tend to be more expansive and less crowded. Many resorts offer exciting swim-up suites as a unique accommodation option.
You May Also Like This Related Article:
Picture yourself lounging by a 45,000-square-foot water park or floating down a lazy river without bumping elbows with fellow travelers. You'll even find unique offerings like golf courses, scuba diving spots, and surf simulators that simply aren't possible on a ship. Plus, many resorts give you access to their sister properties, expanding your options even further.
While resorts do require more walking between facilities (something to reflect on if mobility is a concern), you'll be rewarded with breathtaking views from your room and the freedom to enjoy beach access whenever you want.
However, with the exception of inside cabins, both types of vacation will offer plenty of natural light and ocean breezes flowing through your accommodations and overall environment to create that perfect vacation vibe you're seeking.
Scheduling Your Days On A Winter Escape
Throughout your winter escape planning, scheduling flexibility will be a key factor when choosing between cruises and all-inclusive resorts.
When you're at an all-inclusive resort, you'll enjoy complete itinerary freedom. You can sleep in, grab breakfast whenever you're ready, and plan your days at your own pace. This makes for a more restful vacation for families seeking relaxation. Travelers especially appreciate the stress-free environment that comes with not having fixed schedules.
Want to try paddleboarding at 2 PM? Go for it. Feeling like a late dinner? No problem. This relaxed approach allows guests to truly unwind and adopt vacation mode without watching the clock.
Cruises, on the other hand, while exciting, operate on stricter schedules. You'll need to keep track of port arrival and departure times, plan your shore excursions carefully, and typically unless you opt for "my time" or "any time" dining, you will need to make it to meal services at specific hours. Similarly, room service options at resorts will be far better quality and variety than on cruise ships.
While this structured approach works well for some travelers, it can feel a bit rushed when you're trying to navigate multiple destinations. However, to look at this purely as a negative would be unfair to cruises because unlike a land-based resort, on a cruise you will wake up in a new place every morning and the landscape is constantly changing without you needing to hop from bed to bed.
Length Of Your Vacation
While there are quite a few options when it comes to the length of a cruise but typically cruises are seven-day voyages and the shorter cruises are on older ships with less favorable itineraries. On the other hand, you can schedule a 2 day resort getaway in Jamaica if you wanted to ... while a cruise might take you two days just to get there from Miami.
For folks with busy schedules this makes a resort vacation that much more appealing to many people.
Food and Drinks
When it comes to what you're going to eat and drink, cruise ships are both the winner and loser. While typical cruise ship food can be pretty weak compared to typical resort dining experiences, the best cruise ship "specialty dining" restaurants are heads and tails above what is typically available at a most all-inclusive resort. For the sake of this discussion, I am not including ultra-premium resorts like those run by Ritz Carlton nor are we including cruise lines like Seabourn, Viking, or Crystal.
Once again though, this is why it is so important that you work with a travel advisor since they can help you pick the right cruise ship as well as the right resort.
When it comes to bars and drinking, though, cruises and resorts diverge considerably. While most cruises (except our favorite, Virgin Voyages) offer unlimited drink packages of one sort or another, there are usually considerable restrictions and tiers. On the other hand, at most resorts, drinks are included.
Similarly, specialty dining is typically included in the cost of your resort's nightly fee while on a cruise you can purchase meals separately. Some cruise lines like Norwegian and Princess offer packages that make their offering more inclusive and closer to what you might expect at an all-inclusive resort but that can add 50% or more to the price of your cruise and quickly erode's the very attractive price that drew you to consider a cruise in the first place.
Entertainment and Relaxation Choices
Three distinct entertainment paths emerge when comparing cruises and all-inclusive resorts for your winter getaway.
You'll find high-energy entertainment variety on cruises, from Broadway-style shows to IMAX theaters and even robot bartenders mixing your drinks. If you're seeking constant stimulation, cruise ships deliver round-the-clock activities like rock climbing, water parks, and live music in cozy lounges. These floating resort experiences provide endless entertainment options without ever leaving the ship.
For relaxation amenities, both options have you covered, but with different approaches. All-inclusive resorts excel at creating a laid-back atmosphere with stunning pools, beach access, and spacious suites where you can truly unwind. Many resorts even offer celebrity chef options at their on-site restaurants, elevating your dining experience.
Both options for your winter getaway will deliver opportunities for yoga classes, wellness seminars, and spa treatments but resorts typically offer a more serene, unhurried experience. Many resorts also offer golf courses on site or partner with local greens to provide their guests with easy access. For obvious reasons, amenities like this simply aren't possible on cruise ships.
The social scene varies considerably between the two. On a cruise, you're part of a vibrant community that's always evolving, with themed parties and shared excursions creating natural opportunities to meet fellow travelers.
Resort life tends to be more intimate and predictable, perfect if you prefer a consistent atmosphere where you can settle into your own rhythm.
Cruise or Resort: Different Strokes For Different Folks!
You'll find both cruises and all-inclusive resorts offer unique advantages for your winter escape.
It really depends on what's important to you and your partner. Personally, I enjoy both. As a travel advisor, Heather works with clients who regularly book both types of experiences. Ultimately, it's not about if a cruise is better than an all-inclusive resort for your winter getaway. It's more about what best fits what you are looking to experience on your vacation.
If you're craving variety and don't mind a more structured schedule, a cruise might be your perfect match. But if you're seeking a laid-back vacation where you can truly unwind without changing locations, an all-inclusive resort is probably your better bet. Consider your vacation style, budget, and desired pace before making your choice.
If you are interested sailing with Virgin, or want to book a Virgin Voyages cruise, please call Heather at: 630-779-9301 or Heather@FlowVoyages.com
